The collected works of ramana maharshi series#

This should be regarded as the standard and authentic text. In 1926 Bhagavan rewrote the whole work in the form of an essay. It was an immediate success with devotees. Who am I? was first printed in Tamil in 1923 as an appendix to Sri Ramana Charita Ahaval, a verse biography of Bhagavan by Sivaprakasam Pillai. Given the circumstances of the questioning, it is possible that some errors crept in since the recording was dependent on Sivaprakasam PillaiвЂ™s memory of the replies. Sivaprakasam Pillai then went home and wrote down what he could remember of this conversation. Sivaprakasam Pillai questioned Bhagavan in 1901 and Bhagavan wrote down his replies either in the sand or on a slate, After each new question had been asked, the preceding reply was wiped out to make space for the new answer.

The essay version composed by Bhagavan himself is the most authentic because the original question-and-answer version that appeared in 1923 was composed and edited by Sivaprakasam Pillai and was not shown to Bhagavan prior to its publication. It has appeared as a question-and-answer version with the number of questions varying from thirteen to thirty. There are also several versions of the original text, which complicates matters. How do these all compare for authenticity and clarity?вЂ™ДЄnswer: There have been several translations of Who Am I?, some better than others. Question: I have only seen the original translation of Who am I?, the small green booklet, and was unaware that there are other translations. It is a bit of a touchy subject and I suspect that some devotees will disagree with me. These are my thoughts on this topic, along with the reasoning behind them.

The collected works of ramana maharshi series#

I have just dusted off that particular series of correspondence and amalgamated all the points into one presentation. I then found myself defending and clarifying some of the points I had made. Through circumstances that I canвЂ™t quite remember, the reply I sent ended up being posted online. How do these all compare for authenticity and clarity?вЂ™ I have only seen the original translation of Who am I?, the small green booklet, and was unaware that there are other translations. вЂ Which books do you feel are the most genuine documentations of RamanaвЂ™s words and teachings? Even the Talks was published several years after his death, though it reads consistently throughout.